The Best Materials for Soffit and Fascia in Ontario's Climate

Ontario’s weather is nothing if not unpredictable — from icy winters and spring downpours to hot, humid summers. For Barrie homeowners, protecting your home from the elements means choosing the right exterior materials, and that includes your soffit and fascia.

These often-overlooked components play a crucial role in protecting your roof, improving ventilation, and boosting your home’s curb appeal. But to do their job properly year-round, they need to be made of the right materials — ones that can handle Ontario’s harsh climate.

So, what are the best materials for soffit and fascia in our region? Let’s break it down.

What Are Soffit and Fascia?

Before we dive into materials, here’s a quick refresher:

• Soffit is the underside of your roof’s overhang. It helps ventilate your attic and prevents moisture buildup that can lead to mold, ice dams, or roof damage.
  
  
• Fascia is the vertical finishing edge that runs along the lower edge of the roof. It supports the bottom row of roof shingles and holds the eavestrough (gutter) system in place.
  
  

Both need to be durable, weather-resistant, and low-maintenance — especially in a place like Barrie, where temperatures swing from -20°C in winter to +30°C in summer.

Top Soffit and Fascia Materials for Ontario Homes

1. Aluminum

Best for: Durability, low maintenance, and moisture resistance

Aluminum is one of the most popular choices for soffit and fascia in Ontario — and for good reason.

Benefits:

• Weather-Resistant: Doesn’t warp, crack, or rot in fluctuating temperatures.
  
  
• Rust-Proof: Treated aluminum resists corrosion, even in high-moisture environments.
  
  
• Low Maintenance: No repainting or staining needed.
  
  
• Pest-Resistant: Hard for animals and insects to chew through or nest in.
  
  
• Ventilation Options: Aluminum soffits are available in solid and vented styles to ensure proper attic airflow.
  
  

Ideal for: Homes in Barrie that experience snow, ice, heavy rains, and strong winds — in other words, most homes in the area.

2. Vinyl

Best for: Budget-conscious homeowners seeking low maintenance and color variety

Vinyl is another common choice, especially for soffits. It offers some attractive advantages, though it may not be as tough as aluminum in the long run.

Benefits:

• Affordable: Vinyl is generally less expensive than aluminum.
  
  
• Moisture-Resistant: Won’t rot, mold, or attract pests.
  
  
• Low Maintenance: Doesn’t need painting.
  
  
• Colour Selection: Comes in a wide range of colours and styles.
  
  

Things to Consider:

• Can become brittle in extreme cold, which may lead to cracking if not properly installed.
  
  
• May not last as long as aluminum in harsh Ontario climates.
  
  

Ideal for: Homeowners looking for a more affordable option and a quick aesthetic upgrade, but not dealing with significant weather exposure.

3. Wood (Painted or Treated)

Best for: Traditional or heritage-style homes where aesthetics are the top priority

Wood offers a classic look but comes with higher maintenance — and it doesn't always hold up well in Ontario’s extreme climate.

Benefits:

• Beautiful Appearance: Can be painted or stained to match historic or custom homes.
  
  
• Customizable: Easy to cut and shape for unique design needs.
  
  

Drawbacks:

• Requires Regular Maintenance: Needs to be painted or sealed every few years.
  
  
• Susceptible to Rot, Mold, and Insects: Especially in damp conditions.
  
  
• Can Warp or Crack with temperature changes or moisture.
  
  

Ideal for: Heritage homes or homeowners prioritizing design over durability.

4. Composite or Engineered Materials

Best for: Homeowners seeking a high-end, modern, and long-lasting solution

Some manufacturers offer composite soffit and fascia materials made from engineered wood, PVC, or fiber cement blends.

Benefits:

• Highly Durable: Designed to resist warping, rot, and pests.
  
  
• Low Maintenance: Usually factory-finished and resistant to weather.
  
  
• Stylish Appearance: Mimics the look of wood without the upkeep.
  
  

Drawbacks:

• Higher Cost: More expensive than vinyl or aluminum.
  
  
• Limited Local Availability: Not all products are readily available in Barrie.
  
  

Ideal for: High-end homes or renovations where budget allows for premium materials.

Our Top Recommendation for Barrie Homes: Aluminum

At Reynolds Brothers Exteriors, we typically recommend aluminum soffit and fascia for most Barrie homes. It offers the best balance of:

• Durability in all four seasons
  
  
• Protection from pests and moisture
  
  
• Long-term value with minimal upkeep
  
  

We use high-quality aluminum products that are custom-fit to your home, available in a variety of colours, and professionally installed to meet Ontario building codes and withstand our challenging climate.

Need an Expert Opinion? We’re Here to Help.

Choosing the right soffit and fascia materials is more than just an aesthetic decision — it’s an investment in your home’s protection and longevity.

If you’re unsure which option is right for your home, Reynolds Brothers Exteriors offers free consultations and expert recommendations tailored to your budget, style, and location.

Serving Barrie and surrounding areas with professional exterior solutions — all year round.

‍